Authors : Seungwoo Lee

Volume/Issue : Volume 10 - 2025, Issue 9 - September

Google Scholar : https://tinyurl.com/2p9k8s4e

Scribd : https://tinyurl.com/23smj3bb

DOI : https://doi.org/10.38124/ijisrt/25sep437

Note : A published paper may take 4-5 working days from the publication date to appear in PlumX Metrics, Semantic Scholar, and ResearchGate.

Note : Google Scholar may take 30 to 40 days to display the article.

Abstract : The paper reconsiders the “Reading War” in detail, analysing the evolution of literacy instruction through a psycholinguistic and linguistic lens. It examines the historical development of whole-language and phonics approaches, explores their effectiveness for diverse learners, and evaluates their effectiveness. The paper argues that the context-sensitive, linguistically informed, and equity-driven model of reading instructions effectively links clear phonics instructions with critical thinking and strategies that promote comprehension. This paper also discusses sociolinguistic and equity dimensions by providing details regarding language variations, the role of literacy, and how equity arguments are effective for students during studies, with some case studies. Some recommendations include continued research, policy reforms, and teacher training aligned with evidence-based practices to ensure equitable literacy for all students.

Keywords : Whole Language, Reading Wars, Equity, Structured Literacy, Linguistics, Teacher Training, Psycholinguistics, Educational Policy.

References :

1. Al-Shidhani, Thuraya Ahmed, and Vinita Arora. "Understanding dyslexia in children through human development theories." Sultan Qaboos University Medical Journal 12, no. 3 (2012): 286. (2012).
2. Antvorskov, Khayreyah. "Neurodivergent Learner like Reading Disabilities and Dyslexia." (2023).
3. Arc.educationapps.vic.gov. Victoria's approach to teaching reading F-2, 2025. .
4. Bosnes, Ingunn and Eystein Stordal, Hans M. Nordahl, Tor Å. Myklebust and Ove Almkvist. Ole Bosnes. "Processing speed and working memory are predicted by components of successful ageing: a HUNT study." BMC Psychology 10, no. 1 (2022): 16. (2022).
5. Bowman-Perrott, Lisa, Lakshmi Mahadevan, Matthew Etchells, and Sharon deMarín. "Assessing the academic, social, and language production outcomes of English language learners engaged in peer tutoring: A systematic review." One 1:1 tutoring study showed ELLs increased five additional months of learning in a year by comparing with national averages that achieved partial results with native speakers (2016).
6. Bradbury, Alice. "The impact of the Phonics Screening Check on grouping by ability: A 'necessary evil'amid the policy storm." British Educational Research Journal 44, no. 4 (2018): 539-556. (2018).
7. Carol Moxam. "The link between language and spelling: What speech-language pathologists and teachers need to know." Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 51, no. 4 (2020): 939-954. (2020).
8. Cave, Gilbert T. Why Johnny Can't Read. 2022. .
9. Cothran, Martin. This is the History of Phonics. 2014. .
10. DeLuca, Christopher, and Bronwen Cowie, Christine Harrison, Andrew Coombs, Andrew Gibson, Suzanne Trask, Jill Willis. "Policies, programs, and practices: Exploring the complex dynamics of assessment education in teacher education across four countries." In Frontiers in Education, vol. 4, p. 132. Frontiers Media SA, 2019. (2019).
11. Ehri, Linnea C., Steven A. Stahl, Dale M. Willows, Simone R. Nunes. "Systematic phonics instruction helps students learn to read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel's meta-analysis." Review of educational research 71, no. 3 (2001): 393-447. (2001).
12. Eng, Monica. Illinois gets re-hooked on phonics. 2023. .
13. Fabio Richlan. "Developmental dyslexia: dysfunction of a left hemisphere reading network." Frontiers in human neuroscience 6 (2012): 120. (2012).
14. Fathimath Shaheema. "Reading instruction: content knowledge, self-perceived teaching abilities and beliefs of teachers in key stage one of Maldivian schools." (2023).
15. Feizpour, Azadeh, and Farshad A. Mansouri. Helena C. Parkington. "Cognitive sex differences in effects of music in the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test." Psychology of Music 48, no. 2 (2020): 252-265. (2020).
16. Gamse, Beth C., Megan Horst, Beth Boulay, and Fatih Unlu. Robin Tepper Jacob. "Reading First Impact Study. Final Report. NCEE 2009-4038." National Centre for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance (2008). (2008).
17. Gardner, Keith. "THE INITIAL TEACHING ALPHABET (i.t.a.) AND REMEDIAL READING PROGRAMME." The Slow Learning Child, 13(2), 67–71 (2006).
18. Gawne, Linda. "The politics and pedagogy of teaching literacy in the state of Victoria, Australia." Educational Research for Policy and Practice (2024): 1-16. (2024).
19. George, Sigy. Five Pillars of Reading. 2023. .
20. Giazitzidou, Sophia, Susana Padeliadu, Angeliki Mouzaki. "Pathways from morphological awareness to reading fluency: the mediating role of phonological awareness and vocabulary." Reading and Writing 37, no. 5 (2024): 1109-1131. (2024).
21. Gov.uk. Phonics screening check: information for parents. 2025. .
22. Graham, Steve, and Michael Hebert. "Writing to read: A meta-analysis of the impact of writing and writing instruction on reading." Harvard educational review 81, no. 4 (2011): 710-744. (2011).
23. Hansford, Nathaniel, and Kathryn Garforth, Jill D. Grande, Joshua King, and Sky McGlynn. Scott A. Dueker. "Reading recovery: a longitudinal meta-analysis." Discover Education 3, no. 1 (2024): 1-12. (2024).
24. Kostewicz, Douglas E. and Richard M. Kubina Jr. "The national reading panel guidepost: A review of reading outcome measures for students with emotional and behavioural disorders." Behavioural Disorders 33, no. 2 (2008): 62-74. (2008).
25. Kuhlmann, Emily Hope, and Amy Lynn Conrad. "Word reading in boys with isolated oral clefts: comparison to unaffected average and dyslexic readers using the dual-route model." The Cleft Palate Craniofacial Journal 57, no. 3 (2020): 310-320. (2020).
26. Lexialearning. The Science of Reading vs. Balanced Literacy: The History of the Reading Wars. 2022. .
27. Luscombe, Belinda. Inside the Massive Effort to Change the Way Kids Are Taught to Read. 2025. .
28. Mason, Lee, and Maria Otero. "Just how effective is direct instruction?" Perspectives on Behaviour Science 44, no. 2 (2021): 225-244 (2021).
29. Meaux, Ashley Bourque, Ginger Collins, Emily Diehm. "Morphological knowledge: Opportunities for collaboration through a multitiered system of supports." Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 51, no. 3 (2020): 515-530. (2020).
30. Neurosciencenews. Distinctive Brain Pattern May Underlie Dyslexia. 2016. https://neurosciencenews.com/dyslexia-brain-pattern-5789/ nichd. Nih. National Reading Panel: Teaching Children to Read. 2025. .
31. Okur, Mehmet and Veysel Aksoy. "The Effect of Verbal Working Memory Intervention on the Reading Performance of Students with Specific Learning Disabilities." Behavioural Sciences 15, no. 3 (2025): 356. (2025).
32. Pae, Hye K. "Toward a script relativity hypothesis: Focused research agenda for psycholinguistic experiments in the science of reading." Journal of Cultural Cognitive Science 6, no. 2 (2022): 97-117. (2020).
33. Pondiscio, Robert. Reading opens worlds — and NYC schools are finally getting it right. 2025. .
34. Schwartz, Sarah. Lucy Calkins Says Balanced Literacy Needs ‘Rebalancing’. 2020. .
35. Winter, Jessica. The Rise and Fall of Vibes-Based Literacy. 2022. .
36. Yin, Hue Chi, and Nor Aniza Ahmad. "PHONOLOGICAL LOOP AND VISUOSPATIAL SKETCHPAD OF WORKING MEMORY: COMPARISON BETWEEN WESTERN AND CHINESE MUSICAL INSTRUMENT BACKGROUND." ICERP 2017: 138. (2017).
37. Zou, Liye, and Myrto Mavilidi, Yanxia Chen, Fabian Herold, Kim Ouwehand, and Fred Paas. Zhihao Zhang. "The synergy of embodied cognition and cognitive load theory for optimised learning." Nature Human Behaviour (2025): 1-9. (2025).